• Sports Medicine
  • Knee
  • Pediatric Sports Medicine


A fellowship-trained, board-certified physician who’s also a lifelong athlete, Dr. McCarroll was a founding partner of Methodist Sports Medicine.

He earned his medical degree from Ohio State University, served an orthopedic residency at the Naval Regional Medical Center in Portsmouth, Va. and completed specialized training in sports medicine from the University of Oklahoma.

After years spent as an all-state football player for Zanesville High School, competitor on the Ohio State baseball team, team physician, orthopedic consultant and avid golfer, Dr. McCarroll understands that nothing is more frustrating than sitting on the sidelines with an injury. He has devoted his career to getting players back in the game, whether “the game” is starting in a match-up between IU and one of its Big 10 foes, or comfortably sitting in the stands through your daughter’s soccer championships. Dr. McCarroll now limits his practice to walk-in clinic patients at Methodist Sports Medicine ’s North location.

As the father of four children and grandfather of four, Dr. McCarroll believes an important part of being a good doctor is the ability to see your patients as people – dads and moms, grandparents, sisters and brothers who all juggle demanding lifestyles and need to find time to pursue their passions, volunteer and “play” as a family at every opportunity.

Areas of Focus

  • Knee Reconstruction
  • Arthroscopic Surgery
  • Ligament Reconstruction
  • Patella Realignment
  • Meniscus Surgery
  • Sports Medicine


1970 Ohio State Medical License
1977 Board Certified in Orthopaedic Surgery
1977 Oklahoma State Medical License
1980 Indiana State Medical License


2012 Indiana Football Hall of Fame Inductee
Service Recognition/Reception from Indiana University Athletics
Merit Award from the Indiana Soccer Hall of Fame
Outstanding Teacher Award from Indiana University Medical School
Team Physician of the Year
Member of the Herodicus Society, which recognizes contributions to the sports medicine field
Senior Athletic Training Award carries his name
Co-authored numerous publications and book chapters
Commander, United States Navy and Chief of Orthopedic Surgery
Founder, Methodist Sports Medicine


Commander, United States Navy and Chief of Orthopaedic Surgery
Naval Regional Medical Center
Charleston, South Carolina

Professional Appointments:

Clinical Instructor in Orthopaedic Surgery, Medical University of South Carolina, 1976 – 1980.
Technical Advisor to the Indiana State, Medical Committee on Sports Medicine, 1983 – 1984.
Clinical Assistant Professor, Department of Orthopaedics, Indiana University School of Medicine, 1984 – present.
Membership Committee for North American Arthroscopy Association, 1988 – 1989.
State Liaison Committee for North American Orthopaedic Society for Sports Medicine, 1989.
Member at Large Executive Committee Council of Delegates AOSSM, 1990.
Alpha Omega Alpha, Indiana University Volunteer Faculty Award, 2002.
Team Physician of the Year, Indiana State Medical Association’s Commission on Sports Medicine, 2004.

Professional Associations:

American College of Sports Medicine
American Orthopaedic Society for Sports Medicine
American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
American Medical Association
North American Arthroscopy Association
Marion County Medical Society
Indiana Orthopaedic Society
Indiana State Medical Association
International Arthroscopy Association
Mid-American Orthopaedic Society
Pan-Pacific Medical Society
National Athletic Trainers Association
Sports Medicine Advisory Board for TAC
International Knee Society
Herodicus Society
Irish American Orthopaedic Society
American Medical Society for Sports Medicine
North American Orthopedic Education Society

Download PDF

Download PDF

Download PDF



Couldn't find your answer via our site, send us an email and we'll contact you by phone or email within one business day – Monday-Thursday from 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.


©2019 All Rights Reserved Methodist Sports Medicine

Log in with your credentials

Forgot your details?